Adding a "default Image size" to image settings

New Feature Addition · Images & image management · Created by olixfarwall
closed

What functionality is missing? What is unsatisfying with the current situation?

I think a useful tool would be the ability to set a picture's default display dimensions within the image settings itself. That way separate from the BBcode someone could alter the display of an image in a more complex BBcode. Currently, if an image is in a dropdown it is impossible to do something like the following:  
the ability to scale the image or any other functions are not possible within dropdowns. appearing as this on the final page:  
If users wish to alter the image size using the bbcode that functionality may override the images preset size. Possibly doing this with an altered image id? the bulk of this is beyond my understanding but I hope my request makes some sense. 

How does this feature request address the current situation?

The ability to alter an image's size within its image settings would allow for more flexibility with BBcode and make it easier for those new to the platform to create their ideas.   

What are other uses for this feature request?

Giving users the ability to set image size by default opens many ways of shortening the BBcode and the decreasing learning curve required.

Follow up


I must say I agree with the the -1 comments others have posted - I wasn't really thinking of the issue properly and agree that a default image size idea wouldn't fix much and would just overcomplicate many things. However the issue of the Spoiler features content not being able to use the " | " character for things such as Images, URLs, etc. without breaking is my main problem.   I ask that people not vote on this request further as I plan to post a more detailed and accurate request for this issue if someone has not already done so. Thank you to those who pointed out the misnomer of this request and the respectful way it was evaluated.

The Team's Response

Thanks for the suggestion! This is closed because of the follow-up. We look forward to hearing back from you in the next suggestion you create!
Current score

12/300 Votes · +2001 points

Votes Cast

  • -1

    by Those2Nerds
    on 2024-05-09 18:23
    The actual problem here is that spoilers cannot contain anything with a pipe character. This limitation prohibits use of images, tagged lists, URLs, and more when within a spoiler tag.   Adding a default image size to an image would not resolve this problem, and would likely introduce more problems and confusion when it comes to how to add images to articles and get them sized appropriately. If the intent is to have an image only be a certain size, the image can be uploaded in that size.
  • +300

    by MKirk17
    on 2024-05-06 11:18
  • +1

    by Observer of the Stars
    on 2024-05-06 09:14
  • +100

    by JackLink916
    on 2024-05-04 10:03
  • +1

    by Art_n_Zeug
    on 2024-05-03 16:30
  • +300

    by prestonthedm
    on 2024-05-02 23:29
  • +100

    by tjtrewin
    on 2024-04-28 17:14
  • +1

    by SebGreg732
    on 2024-04-27 15:02
  • -1

    by A Revolutionary Skeleton
    on 2024-04-26 21:18
    While I wholeheartedly agree, that using pictures and bbcodes in e.g. a spoiler tag should be possible, I'm not sure, the proposed solution would really make things easier. New users have to then learn two ways of setting the image size. You might need various sizes for the same image in different articles, so setting the size via image settings is useless in that case. I also feel like this would be a more complicated way of implementing the functionality in the backend but that might be a wrong assumption.

    Long story short, while I don't agree with the proposed solution, I understand the problem and think that images with their bbcodes should work in a spoiler tag.
  • +300

    by JetpackMonkey
    on 2024-04-26 12:15
  • +300

    by DramaticDragons
    on 2024-04-25 20:14
  • +300

    by ecl1psed
    on 2024-04-25 09:39
  • +300

    by olixfarwall
    on 2024-04-25 03:12